The 6 Best Ice Scrapers of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Final Verdict

Our top pick is the Moyidea 36" Extendable Ice Scraper Snow Brush, which removed ice and snow with one pass during our testing. In addition to its durable, well-made design, it offers bonus features such as a pivoting head, an extendable handle, and a padded grip.

Our Testing Process

To compile this list of the best ice scrapers, we distributed 21 models to testers to use and evaluate for six weeks. While real-world testing is dependent on weather, we aimed to have testers use the ice scraper at least three times.

Upon receiving the ice scraper, our testers unpackaged it and examined it for overall quality, while noting whether it had features like ergonomic handles and snow brushes. They also took note if the ice scraper felt sturdy or lightweight.

After the first snowfall, our testers tried using the ice scraper without turning on their car’s defroster—if unsuccessful, they used the defroster and tried again. They timed the process from start to finish, until each window of their car was clear of all ice and snow. As our testers cleared their windows, they assessed how efficiently the ice scraper worked, noting if it could cut through thicker ice and whether it was comfortable to hold. If the scraper had any additional features, our testers evaluated whether these features made the product more efficient.

Once finished, our testers recorded the approximate thickness of the ice, amount of sun, outside temperature, defrost settings (if applicable), and how many windows they cleared in total. They repeated the testing process at least two more times (weather permitting) before seeing the product price—the median price of the ice scrapers we tested was $17. Our testers then scored their ice scraper for its performance, durability, features, ease of use, and value, which is based on the product’s performance in conjunction with its retail price.

How to Shop for Ice Scrapers Like a Pro

Size

It’s important to take stock of how much room you have in your vehicle to decide how big of an ice scraper you can accommodate. If you have ample storage space in the trunk or bed of your car, then a longer, heavy-duty ice scraper can assist in clearing off snow drifts from the roof and de-icing large windows in less time. But for those with small vehicles or limited space, a compact ice scraper will be much less cumbersome. We like the OxGord 2-in-1 Ice Scraper & Snow Brush, which is a 17-inch model that’s great for anyone looking for a small, easy-to-store tool.

Features

Basic, no-frills ice scrapers can still get the job done, but there are also models with added features that make clearing snow and ice off cars much easier. SIMA recommends looking for a two-in-one ice scraper and snow brush. “Depending on the weather, a light snow can be removed with the brush,” SIMA says. “The brush is also helpful for removing snow from rooftops, front and rear of the vehicle.”

Additional features include heating capabilities, LED lights, squeegee attachments, rotating heads, extendable lengths, interchangeable pieces, glove attachments, and crusher or chipper attachments. While shopping for an ice scraper, consider what features might aid in the ever-daunting task of clearing off your car. For example, early morning commutes might call for an added LED light, while large cars or trucks could benefit from an extendable arm.

It’s also worth noting heated ice scrapers aren’t worth buying. In our tests, we found that they’re not any more effective than using the defroster on your car. They also took a while to heat up, and every moment counts when you’re outside in the cold.

Ease of Use

When it’s a frigid day and you need to clear off your vehicle, finding an ice scraper that makes quick work of the task is a top priority. Design features like ergonomic handles and cushioned grips can make clearing ice more comfortable. (We were particularly fond of this Hopkins SubZero model, which has a curved design and comfortable-to-hold handle.) We also recommend looking at the weight of your ice scraper—lightweight models might be difficult to maneuver, while heavier options can tire out your arms.

More Ice Scrapers to Consider

SnoShark: This scraper features a durable metal telescoping handle and nylon paddle that quickly cleared snow during our testing. While beneficial for large vehicles covered in snow, it was slightly less effective at clearing ice.

Joytutus 61.3″ Ice Scraper and Long Handle Snow Brush: With a scraper, snow brush, squeegee, telescoping end, storage bag, padded handle, and included gloves, this pick is ideal for someone who wants a versatile yet affordable option. It performed well throughout testing but did require a few passes on snow and thicker areas of ice.

Questions You Might Ask

Do ice scrapers damage windshields?

With proper use, an ice scraper won’t cause any damage to your windshield—but there are a few precautions to follow to ensure that no cracks, scratches, or chips occur. Be sure to use a plastic scraper, because other materials (like metal) can cause damage. We also recommend using only light to moderate force while clearing any ice on your windshield, because tapping, hitting, or heavy pressure can compromise the glass. If the ice is thick to remove with moderate force, defrost the windshield until the ice is more pliable.

What makes a good ice scraper?

The best ice scrapers will have a durable, semi-sharp edge that can push up the edge of ice buildup on your windshield. Based on our testing, we prefer a rigid plastic material, which is hard enough to combat thick ice without causing damage to your windshield. The reverse sides of ice scrapers typically have teeth that you can drag across the ice to create depressions that weaken the buildup and make for easier scraping.

SIMA also recommends choosing an ice scraper with a longer reach for more versatility. “There are some that are detachable so you can use the scraper for smaller spaces (side mirrors, etc.),” they say.

What is the easiest way to scrape ice off a windshield?

You can easily scrape off ice using a scraper, squeegee, or snow brush, depending on the thickness and strength of the buildup on your windshield. If your car is coated in snow and ice, first remove the snow with a brush or foam snow broom before tackling the ice. Using the defrost setting on your vehicle before starting will also make the process easier.

“After clearing ice with the scraper, if there are chunks or leftover ice chunks on the windows, remove them so they can't fly off and possibly hit and damage other cars,” says SIMA. “Beyond the ice, make sure you remove snow from the car to prevent blowing, which can reduce your visibility and the visibility of those behind you if it blows back toward them.”

Take Our Word for It

This article was written by Quinn Gawronski, associate commerce editor for Real Simple, who has three years of experience writing and editing product reviews and roundups. To compile this list, we tested 21 ice scrapers and evaluated them on performance, durability, features, ease of use, and value. For expert tips, we consulted the Snow & Ice Management Association.

What Is Real Simple Selects?

Next to each product on this list, you may have noticed a Real Simple Selects seal of approval. Any product appearing alongside that seal has been vetted by our team—put through tests and graded on its performance to earn a spot on our list. Although we buy most of the products we test, sometimes we do get samples from companies if purchasing a product ourselves isn’t an option. All products go through the same rigorous process, whether they are purchased or sent by the company.