Never mind the fact that they are Italian-born, their ancestors brought to France by Catherine de Medici’s chef when she married the Duc d’Orléans in 1533. The delicate, intensely sweet, brilliantly colored macaron is as Parisian as Marion Cotillard. They are beloved by citizens of all ages. They are the go-to dessert to bring to any dinner party. All this is why, as my family and I plotted a long-awaited trip to Paris (I’d visited the city briefly in college, just long enough to sample a few macarons; my wife and daughters had never been), my dreams turned cookie-ward. The minute our plane touched down at de Gaulle, I announced that we’d be scouring Paris to find the platonic ideal of the sweet. No, I said, these aren’t the shredded-coconut macaroons—note the extra o in that name—of America. Think of them as Oreos—sugary, buttery sandwiches of multiple flavors with creamy insides. But Parisian Oreos, laden with culture and sophistication and twice as much sugar. My family smiled. Game on.

Ladurée Champs-Élysées

We began our hunt in the 8th Arrondissement, with the most historic macarons in Paris. It was Ladurée bakery that in 1862 took two macaron shells and married them with a velvety ganache filling. The recipe hasn’t changed since.

VERDICT

Per my daughters, the raspberry was clearly the front-runner, and it was accented well by a cup of café au lait in the Ladurée’s suitably belle epoque tearoom. But the très cher price made it taste a little . . .comment dites-vous? . . . extravagant?

75 Av. des Champs-Élysées, +33-1-40-75-08 -75, laduree.com

Grégory Renard Cacao et Macarons

Second day, 7th Arrondissement. Divide and conquer: Eiffel Tower for me and my 8-year-old daughter, Lilly, and tiny Grégory Renard Cacao et Macarons for my wife, Kimberly, and daughter Maddy.

VERDICT

Wife and Maddy said the chocolate sea-salt macarons were the best they’ve ever had. But they saved none for Lilly and me. Grégory Renard’s tiny cocoa-colored shop was warm and inviting. That in no way made up for me not having a macaron.

120 Rue Saint-Dominique, +33-1-47-05-19-17

macarons in Parispinterest
Getty Images
Macarons in Paris

Jean-Paul Hévin Chocolatier

After spending hours at the Louvre, we hunted for a macaron joint as artistic as the building we’d just left. We found it at Jean-Paul Hévin Chocolatier: Its glass and steel design echoes the Louvre’s I.M. Pei glass pyramid.

VERDICT

Jean-Paul’s macarons are works of art but more surreal Magritte than, say, Cézanne. Nontraditional combos include white-chocolate biscuits with grapefruit ganache and a violet chocolate biscuit with violet ganache that was, well, violet-y.

231 Rue St. Honoré, +33-1-55-35-35-96, jeanpaulhevin.com/en

Pâtisserie Gérard Mulot

But had we found the ultimate macaron? We could arrive at no consensus. Then, on our last day in Paris, we went to the 4th Arrondissement to view the Cathédrale de Notre-Dame. And we found Pâtisserie Gérard Mulot nearby.

VERDICT

No frills. No gimmicks. No impressive history. Ils ne parlent pas l’anglais. Just a custom bakery offering incomparable macarons. The coffee-flavored ones were the best of a sublime lot. Said daughter Lilly firmly, “These are the kind of macarons I like to eat.”

76 Rue de Seine, +33-1-43-26-85-77, gerard-mulot.com

Like what you see? Get your free issue of Airbnb magazine.

This story originally appeared in the 2017 June/July issue of Airbnbmag.